*page 12*
Carlotta No!
Cholet Please! I have other reason for doing this. Ask no more. (He hurries out.)
PROP ROOM. The Phantom is standing in the open wall panel.
Phantom He wants you to do what?
Christine Sing Marguerite in Faust.
Phantom: When did he tell you this?
Christine (nervous): At the bistro. Right after I finished singing. It was such a triumph! I wanted to come back and tell you right away. But Carlotta insisted that I go off with her to celebrate. That's why I was so late.
Phantom (flat):  Well. That's certainly good news. We have a lot of work ahead of us. (He turns to leave.)
Christine: I lied to you just now. (He turns back.) Monsieur Cholet told me just a little while ago. I wasn't with him or Carlotta after the bistro. I was with the Count. I shouldn't have lied. I'm not sure why I did. I suppose I thought you'd be jealous. (Pause.) And I didn't want to hurt you. (Hugs him. He stiffens.) None of this would have ever happened without you!
LEDOUX'S OFFICE. Cholet is with Ledoux.
Ledoux: All right, monsieur. If you're certain the Phantom will be there, the police will be there too.
CHRISTINE"S DRESSING ROOM. Christine, in costume for her debut, hears a knock on the door.
Christine (nervous):  Yes? (The Count enters.) Philippe, is it really happening? 
Count Of course. And I'm not surprised. I always knew you were an angel. (Hands her a rose.)
AUDITORIUM. Box Five is empty. In the box across from it are plainclothes policemen. The Count and Carriere are in the box next to this, unaware of the police.
CHRISTINE'S DRESSING ROOM. Carlotta enters.
Carlotta Just wanted to wish you well.
Christine (nervous):  Thank you. Still can't believe this is really happening.
Carlotta: Oh, it is. Very much. (Slips a goblet from her cloak.)
Christine: You've been so generous!
Carlotta Nonsense. Opera is my life! And you, my dear, have the greatest voice I've ever heard. (Pretends to sip from the goblet.) Ahh!
Christine: What's that?
Carlotta Oh, just a little something made of herbs. Most opera singers use this before going on. Helps steady the nerves. I'm a bit nervous too, you know. How you do tonight affects my reputation as well as yours.
Christine Please.
Carlotta Sorry. Didn't mean to worry you. (Seems to sip again from the

v
*Page 13*
goblet.) I'm just so nervous for you that without this I don't think I'd even be able to talk.
Christine: Could I have some?
Carlotta Why! Are you nervous?
Christine More than I've ever been.
Carlotta Well, then it would probably do you good. (Christine takes the goblet she holds out.)
STAGE. As Christine tries to sing, no sound comes out. Finally, a squawk comes out. The audience begins to hiss and boo. Christine freezes.
COUNT'S BOX. Carriere rises.
Carriere (shouts): Bring down the curtain!
BACKSTAGE. Stagehands try to lower the curtain, but the ropes are knotted. The Phantom appears, pulls a sword from his cane, and hacks at a very thick rope.
AUDITORIUM. A huge chandelier crashes down, plunging the theater into darkness. People scream.
BACKSTAGE. The Phantom carries off Christine, who is unconscious.

--* Act 2 *---
PHANTOM'S LAGOON. Christine lies in a gondola, which the Phantom poles into the distance.
BACKSTAGE, as candles are being lit.
Count (to Ledoux: It is obvious - that masked fiend has taken her!
Ledoux Well, it is not obvious to me.
Count: Fine! Then I'll go down after her myself!
Ledoux: Monsieur! If you do, I assure you, you will not come back alive.
PHANTOM'S DOMAIN. The Phantom carries Christine into his palace. Altough made of opera flats and props, it is enchanting.
CHRISTINE'S ROOM. The Phantom gently puts Christine on a canopied bed. She sits up, looks around in alarm.
Phantom It's all right. (She smiles and lies back. He covers her with comforter and sings a lullaby in a voice as sublime as hers. She falls asleep. He kisses her hand and exits.)
CHRISTINE'S DRESSING ROOM. The Phantom finds the goblet Carlotta brought, tastes a drop in the bottom and flings it away.
CARLOTTA'S DRESSING ROOM. Carlotta is brushing her hair.
Phantom's Voice Hello, Carlotta. (She turns and sees him in an open wall panel.) I have something for you. (Carries a trunk to her.) I hope it's to your liking. (Opens it. Rats swarm out.) Rats for a rat. (She faints.)
CHRISTINE'S ROOM. Christine wakes and sits up.
Christine: Maestro? (Sees a lacy white dress on a clothes rack.)
CORRIDOR. Christine, wearing the white dress, enters a nursury. On a wall is a portrait of a woman in the same white dress. In a cradle is a doll with no head!
MUSIC ROOM. The Phantom, seen from behind, is playing a flute. His mask is beside him. Carriere enters
Carriere Erik? (The Phantom puts on his mask.) You must give her back. If you don't, they'll come down here and bring her back themselves. And they'll kill you in the process.
Phantom (turns around):  That may not be as easily accomplished as you think. An assault from above is not exactly unexpected, you know. And I've had more than enough time to get ready - my whole life, you might say. I shall simply shore up my defenses and prepare my counterattack.
Carriere: Erik, if you'll let me take her back with me, I know I can convince her not to say where she's been.
Phantom: Get out.
Carriere Erik -
Phantom No one comes down here that I don't invite!
Carriere They will not let you get away with this!
Phantom Well, they may have no choice! Now, you are straining my patience. Get out. I have things to do.
Carriere: If I leave, will you promise to send her back?
Phantom: Of course not! How can you even ask such a thing? The world up there is not fit for her. Up there is where hell is. I will not send an angel to hell.
Carriere: Erik -
Phantom No! She was betrayed tonight. And I'd sooner die than let her be betrayed again.
Carriere: How was she betrayed?
Phantom You think she sang like that from nerves? Carlotta poisoned her. (Carriere is shocked.) And it's your doing. This company was in your trust! And you turned it over to people who care nothing for beauty.
Carriere: I had no choice.
Phantom You could have burned this place down! Better in ashes and memory than this. Send her back?
Carriere Erik -
Phantom: Never! I may be the most hideous of God's creatures, but I am not hideous enough to do that.
Carriere Then they will come down here with torches and guns. Erik, I can't protect you anymore.
Phantom Fear not. It's they who'll need protecting here, not I.
Carriere What do you mean?
Phantom One push of a certain level, and the opera season is gone forever.
Carriere: Erik!
Phantom I have lived my entire life in a tomb. Why should I fear one now?
Carriere: But she'll die too!
Phantom And to a better place she'll quickly go.
Carriere You're sure of that?
Phantom I am indeed. For as long as I can remember, I have dreamed one sweet dream only. And though that sweet dream came in countless shapes and guises, it was what sustained me. I now know it was of her that I dreamed. (Pause.) I was born to live down here. But till now, I have never known quite why. (Pause.) Well, I was born so she could come and save me! For that is what she's done. She is the reason I was born. (Carriere stares at him in horror.) You seem startled. Did you think me incapable of such emotion? Well, it seems I'm not. What an astounding discover! Makes everything I've been through worth the waiting and the pain. (Almost a laugh.) What pain? The pain was a dream. All was a dream till this. When the gods give you a gift like that, you do not send it back. (Pause.) I love her, Gerard. And I believe, with any luck, in time, she will learn to love me. The gods would be cruel indeed to have sent her otherwise. (Pause.) I don't want you ever to come here again. From now on she will be all I need. But I thank you for all you've done for me in the past. (Carriere leaves.)
PHANTOM'S PALACE. The Phantom

*page 14*
emerges with a dynamite detonator in hand. Carriere watches from the shadows.
NURSERY. Christine, hearing footsteps, turns to the door.
Christine: Maestro?
Carriere No, but he's nearby, so we haven't much time. You must get out.
Christine: Who are you?
Carriere A friend. Gerard Carriere. We met at the bistro.
Christine: Oh yes. You said my voice -
Carriere Reminded me of a certain singer's. Unfortunately, it reminds someone else of her as well, which is why you're in great danger. Come. I know the way.
Christine Wait! Please. Where am I?
Carriere Your maestro hasn't told you?
Christine: No.
Carriere You are in the catacombs underneath the opera house. It's where your maestro lives.
Christine: This is a dream.
Carriere Does this feel like a dream? (Takes her hand.)
Christine (pulling her hand away):  That proves nothing! In dreams things usually seem real.
Carriere: Mademoiselle, believe me, for your life depends on this - you are not dreaming.
Christine: And how did I get here?
Carriere Erik carried you here.
Christine: Erik?
Carriere Your maestro. Most people know him as the Phantom of the Opera.
Christine I don't believe this.
Carriere: You had better, because he plans on keeping you down here forever. He thinks the world up there is not fit for you to live in.
Christine: Why does he care so much?
Carriere He is in love with you.
Christine (barely audible):  Oh.
Carriere: I said your voice reminded me of another woman's. That woman was his mother. She died when he was very young. That's her portrait. (Pause.) He doesn't understand your world. You must get out of here at once.
Christine No.
Carriere: Please!
Christine: No. Not till you tell me why he lives down here.
Carriere: He was born down here. And he's lived here all his life.
Christine Why?
Carriere: Why do you suppose he wears a mask?
Christine: He won't say. Only that I'll never see him with it off.
Carriere For which you should be grateful. If you saw, you'd know why he lives down here.
Christine I don't care what his face looks like. I've seen his eyes.
Carriere: Yes. But his face is like death. Darkness is Erik's only mercy. Get out while you can. Erik cannot be

*page 15*
helped by anyone.
Christine: But obviously he was. When his mother died, who took care of him?
Carriere: I did.
Christine Why?
Carriere I was in love with his mother, and she asked me to.
Christine: What about his father?
Carriere I am his father. (Stares off, and another world forms before his eyes.) His mother was the most exquisite woman I'd ever seen . . .
BACKSTAGE, in the past. Belladova is laughing with some other young women.
Carriere (voice over):  She was already in the company when I arrived, but as a dancer, not a singer. I was eighteen, and had come as an apprentice to the manager. And I'd come knowing I wanted this life, nothing more! But when I saw her, my desires expanded instantly.
MEADOW. younge Carriere listens as Belladova sings to him.
Carriere (voice over): It was a voice of absolute transparency and perfection. It was utter beauty. I'd had no idea she could sing at all! It turned out no one knew. (Belladova stops singing and takes young Carriere's hand.)
Belladova: It's our secret. And it's for you. (Young Carriere looks confused.) Singing for me is very private. I don't want to share it except with someone I love.
NURSERY, back to the present.
Carriere: Does that make any sense to you?
Christine Yes.
Carriere I thought it was selfish of her. Selfish of me is more like it. I said that gift like that should be shared with everyone. So she auditioned. And though she was petrified and didn't sing nearly as well as I knew she could, everone said she was magnificent. And she was hired. She became the toast of Paris overnight. She pretended the adoration pleased her, but I knew it didn't. Her voice lost its transparency. Some part of her was closing off. As best she could, she was protecting herself. (Turns and stares out the window.) It ended, as it had begun, because of me. What she didn't know was that I'd come to Paris as a married man.
Christine Married?
Carriere It was the reason I came. I'd been married less than a month. The details don't matter. What matters is, I didn't love the girl and she felt the same antipathy toward me. So, as soon as possible, with her blessings, I left. For a Catholic, end of story, end of married life. I hadn't told any of this to Belladova, mostly because it never occurred to me I should. I guess I thought, why ruin things? This dream's too sweet to end.
SIDEWALK, in the past. Young Carriere and Belladova are walking along the River Seine. Belladova is in bliss.
Belladova I saw the doctor this morning. I didn't want to say anything till absolutely sure. (Lovingly.) Let's get married. (He turns away grimly.) What's wrong?
NURSERY, in the present.
Carriere I think it was not that I'd been married that affected her so badly but the lie. She'd asked me about my past and I'd never told her. To mortals such as me, betrayal is a part of life, but not to her. Her love and voice and trust were of a piece. And when one went, she came apart. She lost her voice almost immediately. A few weeks later, she herself was gone. Then one day I saw her.
STREET, in the past. Belladova, pregnant and dishevelled, buys some herbs from a gypsy woman and starts to swallow them. Young Carriere rushes over and takes the drugs from her hand.
Carriere (voice over):  I didn't know whether she was trying to kill herself or our child. The time for birth had come, and she asked me to take her back to where she was living. It was a few levels under the stage of the opera house, where horses are stalled. How she had managed to survive for this long, I'll never know. I told no one I'd found her.
HORSE STALL. Belladova holds an infant in her arms.
Carriere (voice over): Where else could she go? To a madhouse, yes. Here at least she'd have me to care for her. And when I wasn't there, she'd have her dreams. (Opera music.) One could ever hear music filtering down from above. It's what kept my son alive.
NURSERY, in the present.
Carriere His face was like nothing I'd ever seen! As beautiful as she had been, that's how monstrous Erik was. (Pause.) I think the hardest part for me was realizing that she truly saw nothing ugly in this child at all. To her, he was beauty itself. Since it was airless in the horse stall, I led them down, lower and lower, to this domain. There was light down here. It filtered in through the gates on the Rue Scribe. And I built them a lean to. She'd sing to him for hours. Then one night she died. Fever of some sort. Erik was three. She'd begged me to care for him. So I watched over him. With his mother gone, he cried. And at night, when the opera house was empty, his cries were heard above. And the legend of the opera ghost was born. I'd become the manager by then. To make sure no one discovered him, I allowed this ghost story to grow. The mask didn't come till later.
LAGOON, in the past. A boy of six stares into the lagoon, screams, and runs to his father.
NURSERY, in the present.
Carriere: He thought it was a sea monster.
Christine: What did you tell him?
Carriere That it was in fact himself. That was not an easy day.
Christine: Did he know you were his father then?
Carriere: No. He still doesn't know. He thinks I'm some kind of uncle.
Christine: Why?
Carriere: Cowardice. I knew some day I'd have to abandon him. And I didn't want to leave knowing he knew his father had not taken him along. (Pause.) Erik has been more than a son. He has also been my partner and my guide. He has unerring taste. He gets that from his mother, not me. (Stares off.) For thirty years, he has been the real director of this opera house, not I. We were a great company because of him. Every major decision, from repertoire to choice of

*page 16*
props, was his! My only talent was keeping him alive. But I must leave now, and he cannot. (Turns to her.) You must leave as well. For his sake as much as yours. Unfortunately, through you, he has come to believe that what's impossible . . . is not. If you love my son at all, please do not give him any more false hope. If you do, you will crush him utterly. And in the process, you will perish too. (Beat.) You were born for sunlight. Erik was born to live in darkness and in dreams. I know the way. Come. (Reaches for her hand.)
Christine: No. You want me to leave him without so much as a word? He deserves better than that from me, I think.
Carriere: If you wait, he will not let you go back at all.
Christine: I don't believe that. Especially after everything you've said. I will go after I have talked with him.
Carriere You're making a mistake.
Christine: How do I get out? (Silence.) Please!
Carriere (dismally, points to a window):  Watch through there. See how I go and try the same. I'll cut an arrow in the lowest stone at every turn. (Pause.) I wish you'd come.
Christine: It would hurt him far too much.
Carriere Not if you left now! Now he doesn't know you've found out that what he wants more than anything is you.
Christine (after a pause):  I'm not afraid. I know his heart.
Carriere So do I. Unfortunately, there is more to him than that. Get out as soon as possible! (Exits.)
MUSIC ROOM. Christine enters. The Phantom, his back to her, is playing a flute without his mask. He senses her presence, puts on the mask, and turns.
Phantom: Did you sleep well?
Christine (nervous):  Yes.
Phantom: It's a nice room, I think. Pleasant water view.
Christine Yes.
Phantom (cheerful): Well! What shall we do today? (Silence.) How about a picnic?
Christine Picnic?
Phantom Yes. Through the woods. By the water's edge. And while we stroll, I can show you my domain.
Christine: But it's night.
Phantom: Not for long. (Snaps a finger. Through the windows, dawn begins. Curtains billow.) Feels like a warm day.
OUTSIDE PALACE. Machinery creates the breeze. A system of reflectors directs the glow of lights.
MUSIC ROOM. Christine is astonished.
Phantom: A hat would be nice, I think. (Puts on a hat at a jaunty angle.) And a walking stick. (He takes his swordcane, then lifts up a picnic basket.) So! All set then. Shall we go? (One wall slides open, revealing a forest. The trees are props, but enchanting.)
"FOREST." They stroll along.
Phantom: You seem chilly. Dawn's not fully with us yet. So, a shawl would be welcome. Let's see. (Finds a shawl in the basket.) Yes! How fortunate! (Puts the shawl over her shoulders.) My heart has been wintry cold for so very long. Suddenly it's not. (Looks around.) Do you like these woods of mine? This ancient glade of elms and oak?
Christine (nervous): Yes. Very much.
Phantom: It stretches on almost forever. There's a path over there. Come. One can get quite helplessly lost in these woods if one doesn't know the path . . . or have a guide who does. (Leads her along the path.) Once there were only endless, dreary vaults in this land - a wilderness of stone, no light at all, no love. Are you warm enough?
Christine: Oh, yes. (Faint sound of birds.)
Phantom: Sh! The morning birds. Pheasants, too, are here, And deer, squirrels, geese, rabbits, fox and hen, and other such intangibles, all playing most harmoniously, like this magic music that I hear. I don't know how these enchanted woods sprang up, but they did. Like a mushroom, there it was! You are magic, too, I think.
Christine I don't know if -
Phantom You are. I have an eye for it. Magic cannot hide from me. You belong in this magic-dappled place. Look, the water! (Shafts of light illuminate the lagoon ahead.) Dawn by the water is a time I particualarly love. We all came from the water, you know. It is our common mother - yours and mine. And now here it lies, all silent and still except for this sweet melodious veil of music. Do you like this music?
Christine Yes.
Phantom So do I. It helps give shape to my dreams. We shall let this music lead us on. It brings to all creatures, fair or hideous, a bliss of solitude. I hear this music, and all inner turbulence is washed away. A calm remains, like glassy water, mirror or mirage, and you're still standing here beside me like some obscure rose. (They come to a clearing.) We'll set our picnic here. (Spreads a cloth.) It is, of all the places in my realm, the most enchanted spot, I think. Would you sing for me?
Christine: If you wish.
Phantom I do. Very much. (She looks away.) Is there something wrong?
Christine: If I sing for you, will you grant me a favor?
Phantom No.
Christine Why?
Phantom: Because you must sing for love and joy, not gain. I will grant you a favor regardless of what you do. Tell me what you wish.
Christine (tenderly): Let me see your face.
Phantom (stunned): You have asked the only thing in my power that I cannot grant. Please, don't ask me it again. I don't like having to refuse you, but to that request I will always say no.
Christine I've seen your eyes. I know your heart. Why not let me see yoour face as well?
Phantom: Because I have no face! What passes for my face is monstrous beyond imagining. No one should ever have to look at it.
Christine I could look at it.
Phantom: Stop!
Christine I could.
Phantom: I ask you, please, to stop.
---* Part 1 *---

---* Part 2 *---

---* Part 4 *---
---* Part 5 *---